Novel Real-Time Nondestructive Technology for Chemical and Structural Health Management of Solid Rocket Propellants



Published Sep 29, 2014
Sami Daoud Michal J. Villeburn Kevin D. Bailey Gordon Kinloch


An innovative prognostics and chemical health management (CHM) technique was developed, for quantifying and characterizing health status of a CL-01 composite solid rocket propellant of tactical rocket motors. The technique is a cutting-edge real-time nondestructive technology approach which utilizes Near Infrared (NIR) spectra (M. Blanco, and I. Villarroya, 2002) emitted by microPHAZIRTM NIR miniature handheld platform, developed by Thermo Fisher Scientific. Benchtop high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and ion chromatography (IC) were utilized as baseline reference techniques for correlation to TM microPHAZIR NIR measurements.To build a quantitative calibration model, near infrared spectra were acquired for twenty freshly manufactured mixes of CL-01 propellant formulae, which were iterated using a D-Optimal full-factorial design of experiment (DOE). Four-hundred eighty measurements were recorded and analyzed using Partial Least Squares (PLS) regression analysis for model building and method development (Schreyer, 2012). NIR results were correlated to spectra, which were produced using HPLC and IC reference techniques and were determined to be in precise agreement. All recorded measurements that were performed using microPHAZIRTM handheld platform were successfully validated with HPLC and IC measurements. An algorithm was developed for microPHAZIRTM NIR thus qualifying the platform as a real-time nondestructive test (NDT)/ nondestructive evaluation (NDE) tool for quantification of primary chemical constituents of CL-01 composite solid rocket propellant. Primary chemical constituents of CL-01 comprise a binder, oxidizer, plasticiser, and antioxidant/stabilizer.Data sets for Shore-A hardness of each of the twenty DOE mixes were collected and used to calculate elastic modulus, tensile strength and percent strain. Calculated results conformed to specification requirements for CL-01 solid rocket propellant, henceforth confirming use of Shore A hardness as a real-time nondestructive test technique for validation of structural health of a solid rocket propellant. This teaming effort between Raytheon Missile Systems (RMS), United Kingdom Ministry of Defence (UK MoD), Alliant Techsystems Launch systems (ATK LS), and Thermo Fisher Scientific demonstrated outstanding ability to utilize miniature cutting-edge technology to perform real- time NDT of CL-01 composite solid rocket propellant without generating chemical waste and residue and to ameliorate RMS technology base to capture incipient failures before the fact. The new technique will further be adapted for use to measure primary chemical constituents of other solid rocket propellants, liquid propellants, and composite explosives. The new technique will significantly reduce costs associated with surveillance and service life extension programs (SLEPs), which are often destructive and requires use of lengthy and expensive test techniques described in North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) Standardization Agreement (ST ANAG)-4170 and Allied Ordnance Publication (AOP)-7 manuals.

How to Cite

Daoud, S. ., J. Villeburn, M. ., D. Bailey, K. ., & Kinloch, G. . (2014). Novel Real-Time Nondestructive Technology for Chemical and Structural Health Management of Solid Rocket Propellants. Annual Conference of the PHM Society, 6(1).
Abstract 171 | PDF Downloads 184




S. Daoud, M. J. Villeburn, K. D. Bailey, G. Kinloch, L. Biegert, and C. Gardner, 2013. “Determination of Primary Chemical Constituents of PBX(AF)-108 Warhead Explosive using microPHAZIRTM Near Infrared (NIR) Handheld Platform”, Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2013.

C. Gardner, and S. Schreyer 2013. “microPhazirTM CL-01 Solid Rocket Propellant Quantitative Results”. Thermo Fisher Scientific, Tewksbury, MA 01887, USA.

C. Gardener, and M. Hargreaves, 2012. “Near Infrared Data Report for PBX(AF)-108 Warhead Explosive”. Thermo Fisher Scientific, Tewksbury, MA 01887, USA.

S. Schreyer, 2012, Thermo Scientific Training Course Tutorial Series: “Building Quantitative (PLS-1) Models”. Thermo Scientific, Tewksbury, MA 01887, USA.

S. Schreyer, 2012, “Thermo Scientific Best Practices for Collecting and Evaluating Spectra from microPhazirTM NIR handheld platform”. Thermo Scientific, Tewksbury, MA 01887, USA.

L. Biegert, and B. Cragun, 2013, “D-Optimal Design of Experiment for Qualification of microPhazirTM Handheld NOR Platform on Experimental Rocket Motor Propellant”, Final Report No. TR-034059. ATK Launch Systems, Aerospace Systems, Brigham City, UT 84302, USA.

G. Bocksteiner, and D.J. Whelan, November 1995, DSTO- TR-0228: “The Effect of Ageing on PBXW-115(Aust.) PBXN-103 and PBXN-105”. Department of Defence, Defence Science and Technology Organization (DSTO).

Mattos et al., 2004, “Determination of the HMX and RDX Content in Synthesized Energetic Material by HPLC, FT-MIR, and FT-NIR Spectroscopies”, Química Nova, Vol. 27, No. 4, pp. 540-544.

Urbanski et al, 1977, “Handbook of Analysis of measures of Synthetic Polymers and Plastics”, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 494 p.

M. Blanco, and I. Villarroya (2002) NIR spectroscopy: “A rapid-response analytical tool”. Trends in analytical chemistry 21:240-250.

H.W. Siesler, Y. Ozaki, S. Kawata, and M. Heise (Eds) (2002). Near Infrared Spectroscopy Principles, Instruments, Wiley-VCH.

microPhazirTM User Manual, Thermo Scientific Handheld Near-Infrared Analyzer. Thermo Fisher Scientific, Tewksbury, MA 01887, USA.

Performance Characteristics of the Agilent 1100 Series Modules and Systems for HPLC. Agilent Technologies, Publication Number 5965-1352E.

A.N. Gent (1958), On the relation between indentation hardness and Young's modulus, Institution of Rubber Industry – Transactions, 34, pp. 46–57.

"Shore (Durometer) Hardness Testing of Plastics". Retrieved 2006-07-22.
Technical Research Papers